Below is the full current Mr. Cupcakes menu. Fox Island Creamery & Cafe regularly carries a choice selection of the options below. However you may order your favorites (in at least 3 days in advance) and we'll have them reserved and ready for you!

$2.50

Standard Cupcakes

All flavors

$2.50

$3.00

Gluten Free Varieties Available

All flavors

$3.00

Place an order

Our Most popular flavors

(Cupcakes That We Have In the Shop Most Often)

Red Velvet

Moist red cake topped with cream cheese icing.

Chocolate Sundae

Chocolate cake, buttercream icing with chocolate drizzle, sprinkles and a cherry on top.

French Toast

Yellow cake with maple syrup and cinnamon baked inside, white frosting with cinnamon on top.

Cookie Jar

Yellow cake with Oreo and MIMIS Cookies baked inside, buttercream icing with cookie crumbs on top.

Birthday Cake

Yellow cake topped with buttercream icing and sprinkles.

Chocolate Overload

Chocolate cake, dipped in chocolate ganache with chocolate buttercream, chocolate drizzle, sprinkles, chips and hot cocoa mix.

Carrot Cake

Yellow cake with carrots, cinnamon and nutmeg baked inside, cream cheese icing with cinnamon and carrots on top.

Oreo Cheesecake

Chocolate cake with Oreo’s baked inside, chocolate cream cheese icing and Oreo crumbs on top.

Chocolate Caramel Swirl

Chocolate cake with caramel baked inside, caramel buttercream icing with caramel drizzle on top.

Fudgie Brownie

Chocolate cake with chocolate ganache baked inside, dipped in chocolate ganache, drizzled with chocolate cream cheese and sprinkled with chocolate shavings.

Boston Cream Party

Yellow cake with Bavarian cream baked inside, topped with Bavarian cream and dipped in chocolate ganache.

Holy Cannoli

Yellow cake with cannoli filling baking inside, cannoli cream icing and chocolate chips on top.

Cookie Dough

Yellow cake with chocolate chips baked inside and a cookie dough ball center. Topped with chocolate ganache, whipped cream, chocolate chips and cookie dough ball.

*Gluten Free Chocolate Sundae

Chocolate cake, buttercream icing with chocolate drizzle, sprinkles and a cherry on top.

*Gluten Free Birthday Cake

Yellow cake topped with buttercream icing and sprinkles.

*Gluten Free Red Velvet

Moist red cake topped with cream cheese icing.

Other Great Flavors

(Cupcakes that Rotate & Are Available for Order)

Southern Red Velvet

Moist red chocolate cake topped with cream cheese icing.

Peanut Butter & Jelly

Yellow cake with PB&J baked inside, peanut butter buttercream icing and jelly drizzle on top. (Contains Nuts)

Fruity Pebbles

Yellow cake with Fruity Pebbles baked inside, cream cheese icing and Fruity Pebbles on top.

Hot Chocolate

Chocolate cake dipped in chocolate ganache with Mini Marshmallows and hot cocoa on top.

Raspberry Cheesecake

Yellow cake with raspberry preserves baked inside, cream cheese icing and raspberry drizzle on top.

Plain Jane

Yellow cake dipped in white frosting.

Average Joe

Yellow cake dipped in chocolate ganache.

Triple Chocolate

Chocolate cake with chocolate chips baked inside, dipped in chocolate ganache with chocolate chips on top.

Vanilla Chip

Yellow cake with chocolate chips baked inside, chocolate buttercream icing and chocolate chips on top.

Chocolate Chip Smoothie

Chocolate cake with chocolate chips baked inside topped with white frosting and chocolate chips.

Strawberries & Cream

Yellow cake with strawberries baked inside, topped with a fresh strawberry whipped cream.

Peanut Butterful Chocolate

Chocolate cake with peanut butter baked inside topped with peanut butter buttercream icing. (Contains Nuts)

Rocky Road

Chocolate cake with walnuts and marshmallows baked inside, chocolate cream cheese icing, topped with walnuts and marshmallows and drizzeled with chocolate. (Contains Nuts)

Lemon Drop

Yellow cake with lemon pie lling baked inside, topped with lemon cream cheese icing.

Chocolate Raspberry

Yellow cake with raspberry preserves baked inside, dipped in chocolate ganache with raspberry and vanilla drizzle on top.

Snowball Fight

Yellow cake with white frosting and dipped in shredded coconut.

Macaroon

Yellow cake with chocolate chips and coconut baked inside, cream cheese icing with chocolate drizzle, coconut and chocolate chips on top.

Bananas Over Amy

Yellow cake with banana purée baked inside, topped with fresh banana whipped cream and chocolate shavings on top.

Tiramisu

Yellow cake with amaretto flavoring, chopped up cake and espresso baked inside, dipped in a white frosting with cocoa powder and a chocolate dot on top.

The Real Diehl

Chocolate cake with a German chocolate spread on top. (Contains Nuts)

Big Papa

Yellow cake with crumb cake topping.

Viva La Leches

Yellow cake soaked in three different milks, topped with fresh whipped cream and a cherry.

Maria’s Flan

Chocolate cake with caramel baked inside, dipped in white frosting and topped with a Flan.

Marble Swirl

Vanilla/Chocolate cake mixed and baked together, Topped with swirled vanilla and chocolate cream cheese.

CUSTOM CUPCAKE ORDERS

Please take note of your flavor selections from above, we will ask you during the next step. The earliest pickup possible is 3 days from today. If you need cupcakes sooner, just come in and select from our in stock flavors!

Mr. Cupcakes Special Order & Deposit

25.00

Fox Island Creamery & Cafe requires a $25.00 deposit on all special cupcake orders. We just need 3 days advance notice and we can get any available flavors from the full Mr. Cupcakes menu. You just pay the balance when picking up!

Quantity:

Place Your Order

Interesting in reading more about Mr. Cupcakes and seeing other locations?

visit mrcupcakes.com

Mr. Cupcakes Menu

CUSTOM CUPCAKE ORDERS