Below is the full current Mr. Cupcakes menu. Fox Island Creamery & Cafe regularly carries a choice selection of the options below. However you may order your favorites (in at least 3 days in advance) and we'll have them reserved and ready for you!




Please take note of your flavor selections from above, we will ask you during the next step. The earliest pickup possible is 3 days from today. If you need cupcakes sooner, just come in and select from our in stock flavors!

Mr. Cupcakes Special Order & Deposit

Fox Island Creamery & Cafe requires a $25.00 deposit on all special cupcake orders. We just need 3 days advance notice and we can get any available flavors from the full Mr. Cupcakes menu. You just pay the balance when picking up!

Place Your Order

Interesting in reading more about Mr. Cupcakes and seeing other locations?