north jersey's best homemade ice cream

FROYO × MR.CUPCAKES × COFFEE BAR × SHAKES × CAKES × PIES

VISIT US BY LAND OR LAKE!

 

Accessible by Land or Lake

Once Upon a Time...

the boaters on Greenwood Lake were looking for a place to have their sweet tooth satisfied. We have answered that calling with Fox Island Creamery & Café. Come in and enjoy frozen yogurt or ice cream with all the delicious toppings you can imagine. Or come for a fabulous cup of coffee and a piece of pie or cake. We also sell a variety of chocolate candies!

We are also proud to serve fabulous frozen yogurt from Froyo World and the famous cupcakes from Mr. Cupcakes.

Mr. Cupcakes
 

Phone

(973) 506-6640

Location

Fox Island Creamery & Cafe
1934 Greenwood Lake Tpke
Hewitt, New Jersey 07421

Cool Season Hours

M:  Closed
Tu:  Closed
W:  Closed
Th: Closed
F: 2pm - 8pm
Sa: 2pm - 8pm
Su:  2pm - 8pm

The people have spoken!

 

Our Customer Ratings

 
 
pacific-dark.png
 
 

HOMEMADE ICE CREAM

All of our ice cream is made from scratch on premises!

Starting with a plain 16% butterfat base, we make our ice cream on premises.  We add in either extract or puree as the ice cream is being mixed and then gently fold in our inclusions as we fill up a tub with your favorite flavor. We also have fresh soft serve vanilla and chocolate. Every cup is special!

OUR ICE CREAM MENU

Flavors change regularly, but click to see our full flavor library! Follow us on Facebook to see what flavors we're featuring this week.

 

Now in West Milford!

Mr. Cupcakes was founded October 2007 by Johnny Manganiotis. There are now five stand alone locations, and Fox Island Creamery & Cafe is proud to bring them to the West Milford / Hewitt, NJ / Greenwood Lake, NY area!

About Mr. Cupcakes

"Our mission is to provide our customers with the best tasting and freshest cupcakes in New Jersey. We bake over 40 different cupcake flavors from the traditional Red Velvet and Carrot Cake to Peanut Butter & Jelly and French Toast. None of our cupcakes are stuffed or filled, we bake our cupcake ingredients right inside."

cupcake box.jpeg
 

MR. CUPCAKES MENU

Fox Island Creamery & Cafe regularly carries a choice selection of the all the menu options. However you may order your favorites (in at least 3 days in advance) and we'll have them reserved and ready for you!

 
FICC-froyo-wall.jpg
 

FABULOUS FROZEN YOGURT

Self Serve Frozen Yogurt × With your choice of toppings × $0.59 per ounce

FroyoWorld has over 100 flavors to choose from - check out a sample of what we have to offer on our menu!

homemade ice cream cakes & PIES

Select from our in store display of ice cream cakes & pies ready for any occasion, or order your special custom cake!

14556506_1787427504875569_2666757390566865203_o.jpg
14993581_1807428989542087_6962327385723671680_n.jpg
14570291_1787427614875558_4331306409175179605_n.jpg
14595685_1791242847827368_3104506899355696712_n.jpg
14650196_1796161774002142_7343936943376828841_n.jpg
14702243_1791428657808787_903937707708710224_n.jpg
14716304_1798958260389160_1219343829636307468_n.jpg
 

FOX ISLAND ICE CREAM CAKE & PIE MENUS

Fox Island Creamery & Cafe regularly carries a nice selection of ice cream cakes & pies for pickup.
We also create completely custom cakes for your next special occasion. Please allow us 3 days time to create your custom cake before pickup date. See our menu and order yours!